Bolivian
leaders find their promises are hard to keep
By Simon Romero
New York Times
LA PAZ
Petroleumworld.com
09 27 06
Vice President Álvaro García Linera could not have been
more explicit in a fiery speech last week calling on Bolivia’s
indigenous groups to defend the government “with your chest, with
your hand, with your Mauser.”
Mr. García
Linera, an urbane sociologist normally known for his moderating influence,
promptly apologized and said his comments had been misinterpreted. But
his remarks underlined the heightening tension that is once again threatening
to tip this Andean nation into turmoil.
Many Bolivians had
hoped that the election last year of Evo Morales as president would
put an end to the instability marked by seven presidents in six years
and angry protests by the country’s indigenous majority, who had
been sidelined from power since Spanish rule began in the 16th century.
The country’s
first indigenous president, Mr. Morales promised to end what he had
called the looting of the country’s natural resources by foreign
companies, and quickly sought to nationalize Bolivia’s energy
sector.
But just nine months
into his term, Mr. Morales, like his predecessors, seems similarly beset
on all sides as the realities of governing have pulled him closer to
the political center.
On one side, the
president is now being portrayed by some former supporters, whose expectations
he had stoked, as a lackey of foreign interests and the country’s
light-skinned elite.
His popularity rating,
though still high, has taken a quick hit, dropping to 61 percent from
81 percent in recent months, according to polls here. A line scribbled
on a building a block from the headquarters of the national energy company
captured the disillusionment. “Evo, traitor,” it reads,
“don’t give away Bolivia’s gas.”
On the other side,
the president faces fresh unrest in the restless lowland provinces in
the east, where the elite of mostly European descent have been unnerved
by his election and are pushing for more autonomy.
Groups in the eastern
province of Santa Cruz, and neighboring provinces, have been chafing
at efforts to rewrite Bolivia’s Constitution in an assembly that
would give Mr. Morales’s supporters more decision-making power.
They have also been
wary of his plans to build two new military bases in the lowlands, with
financing from Venezuela, a move seen as a way to increase the government’s
authority in the region.
Mr. Morales’s
government, meanwhile, charged business leaders in Santa Cruz with “racism”
last week after they decided not to invite him to the city’s main
business fair.
Mr. Morales’s
supporters have also been holding protests. They want the president
to stick to the promises that got him elected, among them liberalizing
laws on coca cultivation and spreading wealth toward the poor.
Yet, despite a steady
stream of militant talk, officials in the new government seem to have
arrived at a grudging recognition that Bolivia must cooperate with the
very investors and lending organizations that are despised symbols of
foreign influence among many of Mr. Morales’s supporters.
Nowhere is this
apparent contradiction more vivid than in relation to Mr. Morales’s
most ambitious project, the nationalization of Bolivia’s energy
resources, which seems to be in danger of not meeting initially lofty
expectations. The government has recently backtracked on several key
measures, ceding ground to Brazilian and European energy companies.
Mr. Morales’s
negotiators, for instance, have temporarily reversed a move to take
control of Bolivia’s two main oil refineries from Brazil’s
state-run energy company, Petrobras, and have failed to provide regulations
so the nationalization can move forward. The government has about a
month left to act on the nationalization decree issued in May before
it expires.
The government also
overrode a move this month by its energy minister to exert almost total
control over extraction of oil and natural gas reserves. Adding to the
disarray, the minister, Andrés Soliz, angrily resigned and was
replaced by the more moderate Carlos Villegas.
Carlos Alberto López,
an independent energy analyst here, said, “It’s obvious
the government has bitten off more than it can chew, but it doesn’t
want to reveal this reality to the population.”
Mr. Morales, an
Aymara Indian and former coca farmer, has largely left carrying out
the nationalization and other economic projects to subordinates as he
seeks to maintain a revolutionary image.
Mr. García
Linera, the vice president, has emerged as a key intermediary between
the government and investors. “These last couple of weeks have
been the most challenging of our government,” Mr. García
Linera said in an interview.
Mr. García
Linera reached out to the United States in a trip to Washington in July,
attempting to win support for renewing trade preferences from the Bush
administration.
In an effort to
soothe tension between the government and business interests in Santa
Cruz, the capital of the eastern province, Mr. García Linera
brokered an agreement last week with regional political leaders to avert
a full blockade of roads into the city.
Still, tension persists
between La Paz and Santa Cruz. One graphic symbol of the dislike many
Cruceños, as the people of Santa Cruz are called, harbor for
Mr. Morales is in the form of a photomontage some people there have
downloaded to their cellphones. It shows the words “Viva Santa
Cruz” written above an image of the president with a gunshot wound.
Such examples of
polarization have arisen in response to radical proposals discussed
in the constituent assembly, like changing the country’s name
to Qollasuyo, an indigenous word invoking the Inca empire.
These ideas contrast
with quiet efforts by Mr. Morales’s government to lure foreign
investment and improve ties to lending institutions like the World Bank
and the International Monetary Fund.
“Seen together,
these actions show that the changes actually put forward and implemented
by the government are very superficial,” said Carlos Arze, director
of a research organization here that studies development issues.
Meanwhile,
recognition that Bolivia is dependent on Brazil, the largest buyer of
its natural gas, is encouraging a much softer nationalization stance.
Mr. Villegas, the new energy minister, said in an interview, “We
want a rational redistribution of petroleum income in the country, while
also telling foreign companies that we want them to profit.”
APX 26 09 06
Copyright
©2006 AFX.
All Rights Reserved.