Electricity imports hit France's energy autonomy

PARIS
Petroleumworld.com, Nov 20, 2009

France has for decades been fiercely proud of its world-beating nuclear industry but is now having to import electricity from its neighbours and could face blackouts this winter.

News of the imports prompted the environmental group Greenpeace to say Wednesday that this was further proof that France's policy of producing three quarters of its electricity from nuclear power was a big mistake.

France decided after the 1970s oil crises to rapidly expand its nuclear power capacity in order to build up reliable energy supplies, and has long exported power to its neighbours.

But ever-rising demand for electricity combined with ageing nuclear reactors have brought that policy under increasing scrutiny.

A third of France's 58 nuclear reactors were down and one was operating at 60 percent capacity at the start of November, according to an AFP survey.

A strike at the EDF power firm earlier this year delayed the annual programme to replace fuel rods at the plants, causing a backlog that resulted in output being reduced for several months to come, industry executives said.

And drought this summer lowered water levels in dams and further decreased electricity production, EDF said.

The power grid operator RTE said this month that suppliers might be forced to ask big industrial clients to ration power use and warned it could even resort to rolling power cuts in some regions.

Poorly-supplied Brittany in the northwest and the Nice region on the Cote d'Azur would likely be the worst hit, RTE said.

The grid operator said this week that electricity production was at such a reduced level that in October, for the first time since 1982, France had to import 458 gigawatt hours from Germany, Britain and Switzerland.

"Selling the idea of energy autonomy was commercial dressing for the nuclear lobby," said an expert on France's nuclear industry, who asked not to be named.

The real problem today, he said, is "the lack of investment, particularly in personnel, in nuclear installations."

"We were assured that (nuclear) power stations with a lifespan of 30 to 40 years could last 60 years. Today, that is posing a problem in terms of supply security," he said.

Greenpeace said in a statement Tuesday that "nuclear energy is not among the solutions for the climate.

"Investing in the nuclear sector diverts important financial resources which, if allotted to the development of renewable energy and energy-saving systems, would enable us to fight efficiently against climate change."

EDF said that its inability to meet France's electricity needs has cost it a billion euros so far this year.

France will in all likelihood have to continue importing more energy from abroad. But industry insiders point out a shortage of high-tension lines to carry that much energy across borders will limit its ability to do so.

Safety fears have also taken some of the shine off France's nuclear industry, which is also a key part of its foreign trade strategy.

President Nicolas Sarkozy has made exporting French know-how a top priority, and China and Finland are already building French-designed new generation reactors.

But alarm bells rang this month when French, British and Finnish regulators called on the French state-controlled nuclear engineering firm Areva to review the design of the planned plants' safety and control systems.

Story by Sofia Bouderbala from AFP
AFP 11/19/2009 08:41

Petroleumworld welcomes your feedback and comments,
share your thoughts on this article, your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us
their views and comments about this article.

By using this link, you agree to allow PW
to publish your comments on our letters page.

Best Viewed with IE 5.01+
Windows NT 4.0, '95, '98,ME,XP, Vista +/ 800x600 pixels